European Auto Shares Collapse Following Ice Cream Fiasco at Shanghai Auto Show, but the Deeper Reason Goes Far Beyond that, with Tesla Involved

Published: Apr 24, 2023 17:41
After the opening of the European stock market on April 20, the six major auto stocks all went down after a higher opening.

After the opening of the European stock market on April 20, the six major auto stocks all went down after a higher opening. As of the close of the day, Renault had the largest decline of 7.97%, while BMW, which was in the midst of the scandal, closed down 3.62% at 100.02 euros. Among other individual stocks, the stock prices of stellantis Paris, Mercedes-Benz, Volkswagen and Porsche fell 5.31%, 3.37%, 3.09% and more than 2% respectively.

More popular news in May

"No One Understands Global Economy Better Than I Do"! Tesla CEO Musk Warns of Severe Recession Looming Large

Massive Aluminium Capacity In China To Be Resumed Or Put Into Operation In H2 2023

"No One Understands Global Economy Better Than I Do"! Tesla CEO Musk Warns of Severe Recession Looming Large

Massive Aluminium Capacity In China To Be Resumed Or Put Into Operation In H2 2023

SMM Comment (May 11): Non-Ferrous and Ferrous Metals Go Down, Oil Outperforms on Firm Fuel Demand in the World's Largest Oil Consumer, Dollar Climbs, US April CPI Data Triggers Financial Market Volatility    

China’s Central Bank Releases Key April Economic Data: RMB Loans Issued to the Real Economy, Newly-Added Social Financing, Newly Added RMB Loans, Balance of M2, M1 and M0, All Recording Enormous Growth       

 IMF: Western Sanctions against Russia Are Ineffective, European Economy Faces Multiple Challenges    

Dollar, Oil, Gold, Base Metals, Ferrous Metals All Go Down, EIA Cuts Oil Price Forecast

China To Actively Expand Domestic Effective Demand And Boost New Energy Vehicle Sales, National Development And Reform Commission Says         

Goldman Sachs, Barclays warn: Fed will not cut interest rates this year

India to become Europe’s top supplier of refined oil products after massive purchases of Russian oil     

Morgan Stanley, Goldman Sachs and BoA Are Pessimistic, Here Is Why    

Global Chip Market Will Decline 20% This Year

Investment Tycoon Charlie Munger Warns A Storm Is Brewing In US Commercial Property Market And The Golden Age Of Investment Is Over      

Chile’s Latest Move Marks One Step Closer to the Establishment of Lithium Version of OPEC

EIA Cuts Brent and WTI Oil Price Forecasts for 2023 as Recession Fears, Inflation and Banking Crisis Overshadow OPEC's Production Cuts

On April 20th, at the MINI brand booth at the Shanghai Auto Show, a blogger took pictures of the incident in which the staff treated Chinese and foreign visitors differently when distributing ice cream, and posted the video on the Internet, which went viral instantly. Subsequently, MINI China's official Weibo issued two apologies on April 20 and April 21.

However, the first quarter report of Tesla disclosed on the same day might be the biggest "culprit” for the battered auto shares. The electric car maker's fiscal first-quarter operating margin was 11.4%, down from 19.2% a year earlier, while analysts had expected 12.2%. After Tesla took a series of sharp price cuts, its operating profit margin has become the most concerned performance indicator on Wall Street.

Later on Wednesday, Musk emphasized on the earnings call that we believe that the pursuit of increasing sales and expanding the fleet size is the right choice at this time relative to low production and high profit margins. "Despite the price cuts we made on some models in different regions in the first quarter, the rate of decline in operating margins remains manageable." Musk said, "We expect vehicle costs to continue to decrease due to improved production efficiency at the new factory and reduced logistics costs, while we remain focused on improving operating leverage."

On April 19 local time, Tesla officially announced that it would lower the price in the US market.

Faced with Tesla's "endless price cuts", Renault said that the price reduction of electric vehicles will "kill" the residual value of the car. "When you cut prices significantly, the residual value falls," said Renault Chief Financial Officer Thierry Pieton. "We haven't made any drastic price changes and we don't intend to." Thierry Pieton said Renault would run its business to maximize value, not market share. According to the data, the sales of Renault electric vehicles in Europe in 2022 ranked third, after Tesla and Volkswagen.

Data Source Statement: Except for publicly available information, all other data are processed by SMM based on publicly available information, market communication, and relying on SMM‘s internal database model. They are for reference only and do not constitute decision-making recommendations.

For any inquiries or to learn more information, please contact: lemonzhao@smm.cn
For more information on how to access our research reports, please contact:service.en@smm.cn
Related News
[SMM New Energy] Another Lithium Battery Giant Conducts Equity Acquisition
1 hour ago
[SMM New Energy] Another Lithium Battery Giant Conducts Equity Acquisition
Read More
[SMM New Energy] Another Lithium Battery Giant Conducts Equity Acquisition
[SMM New Energy] Another Lithium Battery Giant Conducts Equity Acquisition
Lithium battery giant R&D Technology announced that it will invest RMB 50 million in Fu'an Guolong Nanomaterials. Specifically, it will acquire all of Guolong Nanomaterials' equity held by Jiaxing Songhe for RMB 10 million (corresponding to RMB 2.7778 million of Guolong Nanomaterials' registered capital), and subscribe for RMB 11.1111 million of registered capital for RMB 40 million, resulting in a post-transaction shareholding of 10.8696%. The announcement disclosed that Guolong Nanomaterials' net assets as of September 30, 2025, were approximately RMB 93.4737 million, and it has been operating at a loss in recent years.
1 hour ago
[SMM New Energy] A Billion Yuan Solid-State Battery Project Commences Construction in Zhejiang
1 hour ago
[SMM New Energy] A Billion Yuan Solid-State Battery Project Commences Construction in Zhejiang
Read More
[SMM New Energy] A Billion Yuan Solid-State Battery Project Commences Construction in Zhejiang
[SMM New Energy] A Billion Yuan Solid-State Battery Project Commences Construction in Zhejiang
The groundbreaking ceremony for the Heyi Xinneng Pujiang Small and Medium-Sized Solid-State Battery Intelligent Manufacturing Base was successfully held. With a total investment of approximately 1 billion yuan, this base is a key strategic move by Heyi Xinneng to establish a collaborative dual-manufacturing base layout in "South China + East China." It bears the important mission of expanding the East China market, integrating regional industrial resources, and enhancing supply chain responsiveness.
1 hour ago
Idemitsu Kosan Launches Sulfide Solid-State Battery Pilot Plant, Aiming for Toyota Mass Production in 2027
1 hour ago
Idemitsu Kosan Launches Sulfide Solid-State Battery Pilot Plant, Aiming for Toyota Mass Production in 2027
Read More
Idemitsu Kosan Launches Sulfide Solid-State Battery Pilot Plant, Aiming for Toyota Mass Production in 2027
Idemitsu Kosan Launches Sulfide Solid-State Battery Pilot Plant, Aiming for Toyota Mass Production in 2027
On January 29, 2026, Idemitsu Kosan officially began construction of a large-scale pilot facility for solid electrolytes, marking a critical milestone after three decades of dedication to the sulfide route and thirteen years of deep collaboration with Toyota. The plant is designed to achieve an annual capacity of several hundred metric tons, aiming to address key challenges in scaling up production and reducing costs ahead of mass manufacturing.
1 hour ago