Rio Tinto Warns of Risks for Paying High Premiums for Lithium Mines after Plunging Lithium Prices Triggered Acquisition Rush

Published: May 18, 2023 14:19
The sharp drop in lithium prices since late last year has driven major mining companies to rush to acquire companies with early-stage or pre-production lithium projects.

The sharp drop in lithium prices since late last year has driven major mining companies to rush to acquire companies with early-stage or pre-production lithium projects.

However, Rio Tinto, the world's second-largest mining company, has warned that offering large premiums to smaller miners is risky. Rio Tinto Chief Executive Jakob Stausholm said he was "cautious" about acquisitions at current valuations, despite the company's desire to expand its fledgling lithium business.

“Unless you already know you can sell lithium at a high price, it’s very difficult to justify buying at that high a price,” he said. "We have to make sure it's also in the interest of our shareholders, not just the shareholders of the company being sold."

The price of lithium carbonate, used in electric vehicle batteries, has fallen 70% from a peak in November last year. While that has negatively impacted stock valuations for some smaller miners, a growing number of companies are poised to offer hefty premiums as they seek a piece of what promises to be one of the world's hottest commodities.

American Albemarle (ALB.US) has repeatedly sought to acquire Australian lithium miner Liontown Resources, and the latest bid is 5.5 billion Australian dollars (about $3.3 billion) at a premium of 64%. Tianqi Lithium is also trying to acquire Australian lithium mine Essential Metals Limited at a premium of 45%. However, both acquisitions were rejected because the sellers wanted a higher price.

Despite a number of new lithium mine projects coming online in the next few years, potential buyers are betting that these mines will reach their full production, in addition to betting on a rebound in lithium prices. But that's not a sure thing.

Most market players remain optimistic about the long-term demand outlook for lithium, so the trend of offering large premiums to smaller lithium miners will continue. Governments around the world are also working to achieve a faster transition to clean energy. Competition in the lithium industry has also drawn interest from battery makers and even electric car makers. Tesla has been considering buying Sigma Lithium Corp., which is developing a large lithium mine in Brazil.

In addition, Fiona Hick, chief executive of Australian iron miner Fortescue, said on May 3 that Brazil, Chile and Argentina are the most promising countries for lithium, copper and rare earth trading and exploration. Mid-sized or small lithium producers such as Pilbara Minerals Ltd. also see an opportunity to up their bets.

More popular news:

Global Key Base Metals Face Supply Glut, Severe Oversupply for Aluminium, But There Is a Global Copper Shortage

BHP Says China's Real Estate Recovery Will Boost Metals Demand

Trafigura Sees Copper Prices Rising to All-Time High on China Economic Rebound and Supply Shortages

The Ban will Not Stop Exports of Key Raw Minerals Copper, Zinc, Iron Ore from Indonesia, But Bauxite Shipments will Stop in June

G7 to Expand Sanctions Covering Metals on Russia, Promises Further Support for Ukraine

A Bull Gold Market Has Just Begun 

SMM Daily Comments (May 24): LME Base Metals Closed with Losses, All Ferrous Metals Dropped with Iron Ore Plunging, Oil Gained Ground as Goldman Sachs Sees Stubborn Shortage from June

BofA Sharply Lowers Forecast for Oil Price, Global Oil Consumption in 2023

SMM Daily Comments (May 16): Most Base Metals Prices Closed with Losses, SHFE Nickel, Stainless Steel Plunge, Oil Gained on G7 New Measures, US Strategic Petroleum Reserve Replenishment and Supply Concerns

SMM Daily Comments (May 30): Base Metals Mostly Fell, SHFE Tin Bucked the Trend to Soar, Dollar Surged to New High, Oil Fell As Likely Fed Rate Hike Counteracts Debt Ceiling Agreement

USGS Rejects Copper as Critical Mineral despite Huge Shortage and Biggest Producers Push, Citing Misleading Arguments

Copper Shortage Is Irreparable Even after Biggest Mergers and Acquisitions, Here’s Why

Global Aluminium Inventory to Plunge Further amid Supply Headwinds, LME Aluminium Prices to React Fast

Testing Agency Responds to Great Wall Motor Report on BYD to Chinese Authorities

BYD Denies Rumours after Being Reported to Chinese Authorities, Two Top China Automakers Escalate War

High Lithium Ore Prices in Australia will Drive Lithium Prices Rebound, Reasons Prevent Output to Grow

Goldman Sachs Warns of Serious Risks US Dollar Will Lose Reserve Currency Status on Debt Ceiling Standoff

Rio Tinto Warns of Risks for Paying High Premiums for Lithium Mines after Plunging Lithium Prices Triggered Acquisition Rush

Goldman Sachs Lowers Price Forecast for Aluminium, Copper in 2023, Sees Nickel Price Plunging

'Bond King' Jeffrey Gundlach Says Sharp Fed Rate Cuts By Year-End Will Push Up Gold Prices

Zinc Prices to Plunge by 2025, Here's Why

World Bank: Global Commodity Prices to Plunge Precipitously This Year at Fastest Speed since Covid Outbreak

Citigroup Warns European Commercial Real Estate Values Will Plummet 40%, But Sees Medium-Term Opportunity

UBS Raises China GDP Growth Forecast, Sees Earnings from China Stock Market Soaring, RMB Appreciating

Sharp Output Cuts Led to Lithium Ore Shortages, High Import Prices Drove Lithium Salt Producers to Shut Down

US Treasury Bill Rates Soar to Record High on Debt Ceiling Jitters

SMM Daily Comments (May 19): LME Metals Rose across the Board, All Ferrous Metals Dropped with Coking Coal Plunging

Data Source Statement: Except for publicly available information, all other data are processed by SMM based on publicly available information, market communication, and relying on SMM's internal database model. They are for reference only and do not constitute decision-making recommendations.

For any inquiries or for more information, please contact: lemonzhao@smm.cn
For more information on how to access our research reports, please contact:service.en@smm.cn
Related News
[SMM Analysis] Portugal Cancels Construction of Integrated Lithium Mining and Processing Industry
16 hours ago
[SMM Analysis] Portugal Cancels Construction of Integrated Lithium Mining and Processing Industry
Read More
[SMM Analysis] Portugal Cancels Construction of Integrated Lithium Mining and Processing Industry
[SMM Analysis] Portugal Cancels Construction of Integrated Lithium Mining and Processing Industry
16 hours ago
[SMM Flash] SADC Urged to Shift from Raw Mineral Exports to Processing, Zimbabwe's Lithium Ban Cited as Model
21 hours ago
[SMM Flash] SADC Urged to Shift from Raw Mineral Exports to Processing, Zimbabwe's Lithium Ban Cited as Model
Read More
[SMM Flash] SADC Urged to Shift from Raw Mineral Exports to Processing, Zimbabwe's Lithium Ban Cited as Model
[SMM Flash] SADC Urged to Shift from Raw Mineral Exports to Processing, Zimbabwe's Lithium Ban Cited as Model
UN Economic Commission for Africa executive secretary Claver Gatete has called on the Southern African Development Community (SADC) to move from raw mineral exports toward local processing and value addition, calling the region a testing ground for Africa's broader mineral strategy. Demand for critical energy transition minerals including lithium could more than triple by 2030 under net-zero scenarios, with Africa holding about 30% of global reserves but just 1% of lithium output, the smallest share among minerals cited. Zimbabwe was named SADC's primary lithium resource holder, alongside the DRC (cobalt), South Africa (platinum, manganese) and Zambia (copper), with Gatete pointing to Zimbabwe's unprocessed lithium export ban as a policy model for the region. Minerals contribute about 10% of SADC's GDP, 25% of exports and 20% of government revenues, but only 7% of direct employment. SMM View: Gatete's remarks lend regional policy weight to Zimbabwe's ongoing beneficiation push, reinforcing the rationale behind its concentrate export ban as domestic sulfate capacity comes online.
21 hours ago
Sinomine's Bikita Lithium Sulfate Plant Begins Construction, Targets 2027 Completion Amid Zimbabwe's Export Ban Push
22 hours ago
Sinomine's Bikita Lithium Sulfate Plant Begins Construction, Targets 2027 Completion Amid Zimbabwe's Export Ban Push
Read More
Sinomine's Bikita Lithium Sulfate Plant Begins Construction, Targets 2027 Completion Amid Zimbabwe's Export Ban Push
Sinomine's Bikita Lithium Sulfate Plant Begins Construction, Targets 2027 Completion Amid Zimbabwe's Export Ban Push
Sinomine Resource Group's Zimbabwe unit, Masingo Lithium Technology, has obtained EIA approval for its 100,000 t/y lithium sulfate plant at Bikita, moving the project into full construction with contractors China Railway No. 9 Group and Shandong Dadi now on site. Completion is targeted for mid-2027. The clearance formalizes a plan first disclosed in September 2024 and reaffirmed via Sinomine's RMB 5.2 billion ($764 million) fundraising in May 2026, rather than signaling new capital commitment. Bikita becomes Zimbabwe's third Chinese-backed lithium sulfate project, joining Huayou's 50,000 t/y Arcadia plant commissioned July 2026, running near 60% of capacity as of late July and Yahua's Kamativi facility construction started February 2026, capacity undisclosed. Combined announced capacity across all three approaches 200,000+ t/y once complete, ahead of Zimbabwe's January 2027 concentrate export ban. SMM View: Arcadia's slower than nameplate ramp is the key benchmark here if Bikita follows a similar curve at double the capacity, full-rate output likely slips into 2028 despite a mid-2027 completion date. With all three plants now past groundbreaking, Zimbabwe's beneficiation push has shifted from policy to physical build out, the next signal to watch is how strictly the export ban is enforced against each plant's actual commissioning timeline, not just its announced one.
22 hours ago
Rio Tinto Warns of Risks for Paying High Premiums for Lithium Mines after Plunging Lithium Prices Triggered Acquisition Rush - Shanghai Metals Market (SMM)