Deep-sea tailings treatment? Dispute over waste disposal plan of nickel mine in Indonesia

Published: May 19, 2020 10:39

SMM: as Indonesia expands its mining industry to meet the world's strong demand for zero-emission vehicles, it also faces a problem: how to dispose of the resulting waste?

In January this year, the two companies proposed to the Indonesian Ministry of Maritime and Investment Coordination a plan to use this method, that is, deep-sea tailings treatment.

Environmental advocates and researchers worry that efforts to profit from the global clean energy transition will come at the expense of marine life in the coral reef delta, which includes parts of Indonesia and several other countries in the western Pacific.

Nickel mines, which have long been a core industry in Indonesia, have been increasingly driven to meet growing battery demand.

The smelting of battery nickel will produce a large amount of acidic waste full of heavy metals, and how to dispose of the waste is one of the most important decisions in the smelting project.

The company has chosen the deep-sea tailings treatment method to manage tailings, a by-product of extracting metal from the ore, which is another option to build dams to store tailings or spend money to dispose of waste, but this practice is still controversial.

'i don't think we should use the marine environment as a garbage dump, 'said Amanda Reichelt-Brushett, a professor of environmental toxicology at Southern Cross University in Australia. According to his research, the increase in nickel ore in the ocean can destroy corals in as little as four days.

In addition, Merah Johansyah, director of Jatam, said that these projects will have a negative impact on the lives of coastal communities, especially small-scale or traditional fishermen who live to a large extent dependent on marine and fishery resources in local waters.

Ellen Moore, International Mining Coordinator of the Environmental Research and Advocacy Group Earthworks, believes that given the geological and hydrological conditions of the area, the best available technology is to return tailings to pits and tunnels of ore origin.

2020 China Ni-Cr stainless Steel Industry Market and Application Development Forum

Scan the QR code, apply for participation or join the SMM metal exchange group

Data Source Statement: Except for publicly available information, all other data are processed by SMM based on publicly available information, market communication, and relying on SMM‘s internal database model. They are for reference only and do not constitute decision-making recommendations.

For any inquiries or to learn more information, please contact: lemonzhao@smm.cn
For more information on how to access our research reports, please contact:service.en@smm.cn
Related News
High-Grade NPI Smelter Profits Squeezed as Ore Prices Rise and Sales Prices Dip
20 hours ago
High-Grade NPI Smelter Profits Squeezed as Ore Prices Rise and Sales Prices Dip
Read More
High-Grade NPI Smelter Profits Squeezed as Ore Prices Rise and Sales Prices Dip
High-Grade NPI Smelter Profits Squeezed as Ore Prices Rise and Sales Prices Dip
[SMM Nickel Flash] Based on nickel ore prices from 25 days ago, smelter profits for high-grade NPI remained high this week. However, from the current raw material side, ore prices from both the Philippines and Indonesia increased, while auxiliary material prices saw a slight pullback, leading to an increase in the cash cost of producing high-grade NPI from spot ore. At the same time, high-grade NPI prices experienced some pullback, making it difficult for smelter profits to see sustained improvement.
20 hours ago
High-Grade NPI Prices Fall, Expected to Stabilize as Chinese New Year Approaches
20 hours ago
High-Grade NPI Prices Fall, Expected to Stabilize as Chinese New Year Approaches
Read More
High-Grade NPI Prices Fall, Expected to Stabilize as Chinese New Year Approaches
High-Grade NPI Prices Fall, Expected to Stabilize as Chinese New Year Approaches
[SMM Nickel Flash] This week, due to a sharp decline in futures triggering arbitrage selling, high-grade NPI prices fell significantly. However, after the selling activity subsided, upstream quotations and the market center gradually returned to normal levels, supported by cost factors. Looking ahead, as the Chinese New Year holiday approaches, market activity is expected to remain subdued, and high-grade NPI prices are projected to hover at highs with limited fluctuations.
20 hours ago
Nickel Prices Drop: SMM 10-12% High-Grade NPI Down 17.2 Yuan, Indonesia NPI FOB Index Falls 2.06 $/mtu
20 hours ago
Nickel Prices Drop: SMM 10-12% High-Grade NPI Down 17.2 Yuan, Indonesia NPI FOB Index Falls 2.06 $/mtu
Read More
Nickel Prices Drop: SMM 10-12% High-Grade NPI Down 17.2 Yuan, Indonesia NPI FOB Index Falls 2.06 $/mtu
Nickel Prices Drop: SMM 10-12% High-Grade NPI Down 17.2 Yuan, Indonesia NPI FOB Index Falls 2.06 $/mtu
[SMM Nickel Flash] The SMM average price of 10-12% high-grade NPI fell 17.2 yuan/mtu WoW to 1,035.8 yuan/mtu (ex-factory, tax included), while the Indonesia NPI FOB index average price dropped 2.06 $/mtu WoW to 131.2 $/mtu. At the beginning of the week, futures hit limit-down, and nickel prices fell sharply WoW, driving the emergence of arbitrage supplies sold at low prices, leading to a significant decline in high-grade NPI prices.
20 hours ago