US Supreme Court Refuses to Hear Lawsuit Against Rio Tinto Project

Published: May 30, 2025 15:22

According to a report on Mining.com, the US Supreme Court declined on Tuesday to hear an appeal by Apache Stronghold (AS) aimed at blocking the development of the Resolution copper mine, a joint venture between Rio Tinto and BHP.

Apache Stronghold, comprising the San Carlos Apache tribe from southeastern Arizona and conservationists, appealed a 2024 lower court ruling that allowed federal land exchange, enabling the mining companies to acquire land considered sacred by the Apache.

On May 9, a federal judge in Arizona ordered a temporary halt to the land exchange pending the outcome of the appeal to the Supreme Court.

Rio Tinto holds a 55% stake in the Resolution copper mine, with the remaining 45% held by BHP, and Rio Tinto remains the operator.

Rio Tinto has invested over $2 billion in the project, which is set to become the largest copper mine in North America. The mine, the world's third-largest known copper deposit, could meet a quarter of the US's copper demand for decades.

Apache Stronghold first filed a lawsuit in 2021, alleging that the project violated constitutional and legal protections for religious freedom. They claimed that the mine would devastate Oak Flat (Chi’chil Biłdagoteel in Apache), a sacred site where Western Apache people conduct traditional ceremonies, including a four-day coming-of-age ritual for young women.

The group argued that the mine would violate the 1852 treaty, which obligated the US government to protect Apache lands and ensure the tribe's "prosperity and happiness for generations."

Under the National Defense Authorization Act signed by then-President Obama in 2014, Congress authorized the land exchange. The law allowed Rio Tinto and BHP to exchange land for Oak Flat, located approximately 70 miles (113 kilometers) east of Phoenix.

The transfer depended on an environmental impact statement issued in the final days of Trump's first term in January 2021. However, in March 2021, the Biden administration withdrew the statement, halting the transfer.

The US Forest Service (USFS) is expected to reissue the environmental assessment report, potentially allowing the land exchange to proceed as early as June 16.

Rio Tinto is expanding its copper assets to meet growing global demand, with analysts predicting that supply will soon fall short of demand.

In 2023, the company commenced underground mining at its Oyu Tolgoi copper mine in Mongolia, which is set to become the world's fourth-largest copper mine by 2030.

In Peru, Rio Tinto is collaborating with Codelco and First Quantum Minerals of Canada to develop the La Granja project, one of the world's largest undeveloped copper deposits.

Rio Tinto is also investing in greener extraction technologies, including Nuton—a bioheap leaching technology for copper extraction from tailings and low-grade ore, which was jointly developed with Arizona Sonoran Copper.

Data Source Statement: Except for publicly available information, all other data are processed by SMM based on publicly available information, market communication, and relying on SMM‘s internal database model. They are for reference only and do not constitute decision-making recommendations.

For any inquiries or to learn more information, please contact: lemonzhao@smm.cn
For more information on how to access our research reports, please contact:service.en@smm.cn
Related News
"Dianzhong Nonferrous ISA Furnace Resumes Production, Enters Critical Phase Post-Maintenance"
10 hours ago
"Dianzhong Nonferrous ISA Furnace Resumes Production, Enters Critical Phase Post-Maintenance"
Read More
"Dianzhong Nonferrous ISA Furnace Resumes Production, Enters Critical Phase Post-Maintenance"
"Dianzhong Nonferrous ISA Furnace Resumes Production, Enters Critical Phase Post-Maintenance"
On May 18, Dianzhong Nonferrous's ISA furnace started production and began furnace drying, as production resumptions entered a critical period. This annual centralized maintenance covered key areas including in-depth inspection of equipment hazards, replacement of aging parts, commissioning and optimization of production systems, and quality upgrades of infrastructure.
10 hours ago
BC Copper Closed Lower in Volatile Trading, Price Spread Between Domestic and Overseas Markets Continued to Widen in Inversion [SMM BC Copper Commentary]
11 hours ago
BC Copper Closed Lower in Volatile Trading, Price Spread Between Domestic and Overseas Markets Continued to Widen in Inversion [SMM BC Copper Commentary]
Read More
BC Copper Closed Lower in Volatile Trading, Price Spread Between Domestic and Overseas Markets Continued to Widen in Inversion [SMM BC Copper Commentary]
BC Copper Closed Lower in Volatile Trading, Price Spread Between Domestic and Overseas Markets Continued to Widen in Inversion [SMM BC Copper Commentary]
11 hours ago
Chujiang New Material's Copper Alloy Projects Now in Production, Aiming for Full Capacity Soon
13 hours ago
Chujiang New Material's Copper Alloy Projects Now in Production, Aiming for Full Capacity Soon
Read More
Chujiang New Material's Copper Alloy Projects Now in Production, Aiming for Full Capacity Soon
Chujiang New Material's Copper Alloy Projects Now in Production, Aiming for Full Capacity Soon
[Chujiang New Material: Multiple Copper Alloy Strip and Foil Projects Have Been Put into Production, Currently in Capacity Ramp-up Stage] Chujiang New Material (002171) recently disclosed that multiple projects, including the "Annual 50,000 mt High-Precision Copper Alloy Strip and Foil Project" and the "Annual 60,000 mt High-Precision Copper Alloy Rolled Strip Renovation and Expansion Project," were put into production at the end of 2025 and are currently in the capacity ramp-up stage. The company will push forward as soon as possible to ensure the planned projects reach full production and deliver results.
13 hours ago
US Supreme Court Refuses to Hear Lawsuit Against Rio Tinto Project - Shanghai Metals Market (SMM)