German recycling associations BVSE and the Circular Metal Association (CMA) have challenged the European Commission's proposed restrictions on ferrous and non-ferrous scrap exports to non-OECD countries, arguing that the draft measures exceed the legal scope of the EU Waste Shipment Regulation (EU) 2024/1157.
In a joint statement, the associations cited a legal opinion commissioned from law firm okl & partner, which found several potential legal deficiencies in the Commission's proposed list of authorised export destinations. The associations argue that the Commission is using environmental risks associated with hazardous waste to justify restricting shipments of non-hazardous metal scrap, even though hazardous-waste exports are already prohibited under the regulation.
They also questioned the proportionality of the proposed restrictions, pointing out that the regulation requires independent audits of overseas recycling facilities. According to the associations, additional blanket restrictions could undermine recycling economics by limiting access to international buyers.
The new regime governing non-hazardous waste exports to non-OECD countries is scheduled to apply from May 21, 2027. The final list of authorised destinations will determine which countries can continue receiving specified categories of European scrap, potentially affecting trade flows to markets such as India.
BVSE and CMA have urged the Commission to revise the draft and indicated that they may consider legal action if the restrictions are adopted in their current form.

![[SMM Hot-Rolled Arrivals] Arrivals in mainstream markets decreased this week](https://imgqn.smm.cn/usercenter/EXHJE20251217171720.jpg)
![[SMM Analysis] EAF Operating Rate Up 1.24 Percentage Points This Period](https://imgqn.smm.cn/usercenter/FGavQ20251217171717.jpg)
