Adam Weitsman drops plan to buy Roth Steel site after finding toxic disaster

Published: Apr 13, 2015 13:49 (GMT+8)
Scrap dealer Adam Weitsman has dropped plans to buy and redevelop the former Roth Steel property, saying the site's environmental problems were too much for him.
Author: Paul Ploumis
11 Apr 2015 Last updated at 01:08:58 GMT
 
ALBANY (Scrap Monster): Scrap dealer Adam Weitsman has dropped plans to buy and redevelop the former Roth Steel property, saying the site's environmental problems were too much for him.
 
Weitsman said a review of state Department of Environmental Conservation records show the 24-acre property is full of contaminants, including buried metals, petroleum and polychlorinated biphenyls, a toxic chemical compound also known as PCB.
 
While the presence of contaminants on the Hiawatha Boulevard West property has been public knowledge for many years, Weitsman said, he did not know the extent of the pollution until an engineering firm he hired reviewed DEC records.
 
Plumley Engineering, of Baldwinsville, reported that the cost to clean up the contamination would be at least $8 million and that the total financial liability could be many times that number if the pollution has traveled through groundwater to adjoining properties and into nearby Onondaga Lake.
 
 
Weitsman's Owego-based Upstate Shredding is the largest privately owned metal processor and recycler on the East Coast. But he said a liability of potentially tens of millions of dollars would be too much for even him.
 
"We were stunned to find what we found there," he said Friday. "When we got into it, it was a disaster."
 
Weitsman submitted the winning bid of $625,000 for the former scrapyard at a bankruptcy auction in November and paid a 10 percent deposit.
 
Weitsman and the court-appointed trustee for the property recently reached an agreement under which the sale was terminated and Weitsman's deposit was returned to him.
 
After submitting the winning bid for the site, Weitsman announced that he would clean the property and redevelop it with retail stores and a hotel. He said Friday he is disappointed he will not be able to follow through on those plans.
 
"It's really sad because it's an important piece of land," he said.
 
Attorney William Leberman, the trustee overseeing the property for the bankruptcy court, declined to comment on whether a new auction will be held.
 
Roth closed in February 2014 after operating at 800 Hiawatha Blvd. W. for 102 years. The family-owned business filed bankruptcy three months later.
 
Dale Vollmer, environmental engineering manager for Plumley, said some of the scrapyard contains PCBs in a concentration of nearly 1,200 parts per million. Environmental regulations require that any concentration of 25 parts per million or greater be removed, he said.
 
What's worse, disposal of PCBs in the concentrations found at the Roth site would require that the material be incinerated rather than placed in a landfill, he said. Incineration costs 10 times more than land-filling, he said.
 

Data Source Statement: Except for publicly available information, all other data are processed by SMM based on publicly available information, market communication, and relying on SMM's internal database model. They are for reference only and do not constitute decision-making recommendations.

For any inquiries or for more information, please contact: lemonzhao@smm.cn
For more information on how to access our research reports, please contact:service.en@smm.cn
Related News
[SMM Analysis]  Valterra Platinum 2010 To 2025: How Processing Shocks and Price Cycles Reshaped the Business
15 hours ago
[SMM Analysis] Valterra Platinum 2010 To 2025: How Processing Shocks and Price Cycles Reshaped the Business
Read More
[SMM Analysis]  Valterra Platinum 2010 To 2025: How Processing Shocks and Price Cycles Reshaped the Business
[SMM Analysis] Valterra Platinum 2010 To 2025: How Processing Shocks and Price Cycles Reshaped the Business
Valterra Platinum’s 2010–2025 record shows how plant interruptions, inventory backlogs and changing reporting rules shaped refined output across South Africa and Zimbabwe. Platinum, palladium and rhodium followed different price cycles, so output alone could not explain value. Prices for ruthenium and iridium add context, though their separate production is undisclosed. Stronger prices and refining lifted H1 2026 results; lasting gains depend on safety, cost control and disciplined investment.
15 hours ago
[SMM Flash]  Jubilee Reviews Interest in Undeveloped Tjate PGM Project
15 hours ago
[SMM Flash] Jubilee Reviews Interest in Undeveloped Tjate PGM Project
Read More
[SMM Flash]  Jubilee Reviews Interest in Undeveloped Tjate PGM Project
[SMM Flash] Jubilee Reviews Interest in Undeveloped Tjate PGM Project
Jubilee Metals said in its 14 September operational update that several companies had expressed interest in its Tjate PGM project and that it was reviewing the approaches as part of a strategic review. Jubilee retained the South African asset after selling its other chrome and PGM operations; Miningmx reported that a disposal is under consideration as the company focuses on Zambian copper. A sale could transfer responsibility for developing Tjate. Expressions of interest are neither a sale agreement nor financing commitments, and no production timetable has been announced. Any contribution to PGM supply depends on future development decisions.
15 hours ago
[SMM Flash]  Sylvania Reviews Thaba Plan After Lower Feed-Grade Estimates
15 hours ago
[SMM Flash] Sylvania Reviews Thaba Plan After Lower Feed-Grade Estimates
Read More
[SMM Flash]  Sylvania Reviews Thaba Plan After Lower Feed-Grade Estimates
[SMM Flash] Sylvania Reviews Thaba Plan After Lower Feed-Grade Estimates
Sylvania Platinum said in its 15 September annual results that an updated geological model indicated chrome and PGM feed grades at its Thaba joint venture could be below original assumptions. Miningmx reported estimated shortfalls of 15–20% for PGM grades and 8–12% for chrome grades against earlier targets. Sylvania’s FY2026 group output of 95,885 4E PGM oz includes operations beyond Thaba. The partners are reviewing the mine plan, with an updated life-of-mine plan expected in three to six months. Management says Thaba remains profitable under current assumptions. Lower grades could reduce recoverable metal and project returns; the revised plan and profitability outlook remain subject to that review.
15 hours ago