【Flash | Spence Lawsuit Quantifies Two-Tonne Molybdenum Loss from July Stoppages】

Published: Oct 16, 2026 13:12 (GMT+8)
A newly disclosed lawsuit filed by BHP Group’s wholly owned Spence copper-molybdenum mine estimates that stoppages on June 30–July 1 and July 7–8 cut contained-molybdenum output by 2 metric tonnes. The company also claims losses of 400 metric tonnes of copper cathode and 167 metric tonnes of contained copper in concentrate. Using July molybdenum sales of 74.76 metric tonnes and revenue of 5.48 million United States dollars, Spence derived an average price of 33.24 dollars per pound and valued the lost molybdenum at about 146,545 dollars. This is a newly quantified historical loss, not a new October shutdown; the figures remain allegations in a lawsuit and have not been adjudicated.

Data Source Statement: Except for publicly available information, all other data are processed by SMM based on publicly available information, market communication, and relying on SMM's internal database model. They are for reference only and do not constitute decision-making recommendations.

For any inquiries or for more information, please contact: lemonzhao@smm.cn
For more information on how to access our research reports, please contact:service.en@smm.cn
Related News
[SMM Malaysia Weekly Review] Rebar Offer Extend Gains While HRC and Wire Rod Hold Steady; Import Price Advantage Narrows
15 mins ago
[SMM Malaysia Weekly Review] Rebar Offer Extend Gains While HRC and Wire Rod Hold Steady; Import Price Advantage Narrows
Read More
[SMM Malaysia Weekly Review] Rebar Offer Extend Gains While HRC and Wire Rod Hold Steady; Import Price Advantage Narrows
[SMM Malaysia Weekly Review] Rebar Offer Extend Gains While HRC and Wire Rod Hold Steady; Import Price Advantage Narrows
Malaysia's steel market maintained a mixed but relatively firm pricing trend this week, with domestic rebar quotations extending their upward movement while HRC and wire rod prices remained unchanged. Domestic HRC offers held steady at MYR 2,220/tonne EXW, unchanged from October 7. Meanwhile, 16mm B500B rebar quotations increased by MYR 20/tonne to MYR 2,250/tonne EXW, although the latest observations involved different suppliers and may not represent a direct price adjustment by the same mill. C12D wire rod prices remained stable at MYR 2,300/tonne delivered. Despite the continued strength in rebar quotations, downstream purchasing remained cautious. Based on previous stockist feedback indicating discounts of MYR 20–30/tonne against mill reference prices, an indicative stockist selling range of MYR 2,220–2,230/tonne could be inferred if similar discounts persist. However, this remains a theoretical estimate rather than a confirmed transaction range, highlighting the need to distinguish firmer mill quotations from actual market acceptance. On the import front, Chinese HRC offers remained at approximately USD 520–530/tonne CFR Port Klang, equivalent to MYR 2,125–2,166/tonne using the retained exchange rate of MYR 4.0862/USD. This represents an initial MYR 54–95/tonne discount against domestic HRC ex-works quotations. Meanwhile, Indonesian Dexin wire rod offers increased by USD 5/tonne week on week to approximately USD 530/tonne CFR Malaysia, equivalent to MYR 2,166/tonne. The preliminary gap against domestic delivered wire rod prices consequently narrowed from approximately MYR 155/tonne to MYR 134/tonne. Although imported material continues to show a nominal price advantage, the comparison excludes port handling charges, applicable taxes, customs clearance and inland transportation costs, which could substantially reduce the actual savings for downstream buyers. Looking ahead, Malaysia's domestic steel quotations are expected to remain stable to slightly firm, supported by the recent upward movement in rebar offers. However, subdued downstream demand and potential stockist inventory pressure may continue to limit further increases. Meanwhile, the narrowing price gap for Indonesian wire rod could influence purchasing decisions, particularly among steel mesh manufacturers evaluating imported alternatives. Market participants will continue monitoring actual transaction prices, inventory movements and fully landed import costs to assess whether the recent strength in domestic quotations can be sustained.
15 mins ago
[SMM Steel] Vietnam HRC Import Prices Stable as Indonesian Supply Remains Competitive
25 mins ago
[SMM Steel] Vietnam HRC Import Prices Stable as Indonesian Supply Remains Competitive
Read More
[SMM Steel] Vietnam HRC Import Prices Stable as Indonesian Supply Remains Competitive
[SMM Steel] Vietnam HRC Import Prices Stable as Indonesian Supply Remains Competitive
[Vietnam] Vietnam's HRC import market remained broadly stable, with the ASEAN HRC assessment holding at USD 535/tonne CFR Vietnam. Indonesian material remained the most competitive, with some transactions reported at around USD 532/tonne CFR earlier this week. Taiwanese SAE1006 HRC offers for November–December shipment stood at USD 560–570/tonne CFR, although limited volumes were available at USD 550/tonne CFR, with buying interest remaining weak. Japanese HRC was offered at approximately USD 550/tonne CFR, but no transactions were verified. Indonesian supply continued to maintain a pricing advantage in the Vietnamese market.
25 mins ago
[India’s Auto Sales Grow 18.2% in Q2 FY2027]
34 mins ago
[India’s Auto Sales Grow 18.2% in Q2 FY2027]
Read More
[India’s Auto Sales Grow 18.2% in Q2 FY2027]
[India’s Auto Sales Grow 18.2% in Q2 FY2027]
India’s automobile sales rose 18.2% YoY to 8.39 million units in Q2 (July-September 2026), according to Society of Indian Automobile Manufacturers (SIAM). Passenger vehicle sales increased by 30.7% to 1.36 million units, while commercial vehicle sales grew 28.7% to 309,063 units. Festive demand, improved affordability following GST reforms and infrastructure spending supported sales growth. Higher vehicle sales may support demand for automotive steel, particularly flat steel, although actual steel consumption also depends on vehicle production.
34 mins ago